Performance Assessments and Local Alternative Assessments
News & Announcements
Using State-Developed Performance Assessments to Verify Credits in History and Social Science
Please visit the Assessment Resources section of the History and Social Science Instruction webpage for resources to be used in school divisions exercising the option to use state-developed performance assessments, in conjunction with local assessments, to confer locally awarded verified credits in history and social science.
Using Local Performance Assessments to Verify Credits in Writing
Please visit the English, Reading, & Literacy Assessment Resources: Local Performance Assessments to Verify Credit in Writing for support materials to be used in school divisions exercising the option to use local performance assessments to verify credits in writing.
Performance Assessment
Performance assessment measures subject-matter proficiency, requires students to apply the content and skills they have learned, and should present opportunities for students to demonstrate acquisition of the “Five C’s” – critical thinking, creativity, communication, collaboration and citizenship – described in the Board of Education’s Profile of a Virginia Graduate. Performance assessment can be summative or formative in nature. A summative performance assessment evaluates student learning and skill acquisition at the conclusion of a unit, course, etc. A formative performance assessment determines student mastery of content and skills during instruction. As students learn new skills and content, they should be given multiple opportunities to demonstrate mastery through the use of performance tasks. Both summative and formative performance assessments allow teachers and students alike to identify content that has been mastered, misconceptions, and gaps in learning. The evidence gained through performance assessment may be used to guide future classroom instruction.
Information about new resources related to performance assessment will be posted on this page as it becomes available.
Local Alternative Assessments
The 2014 General Assembly eliminated Standards of Learning (SOL) assessments in Grade 3 History, Grade 3 Science, Grade 5 Writing, United States History to 1865, and United States History: 1865 to the Present. Additionally, the Assembly’s action required local school divisions to continue to teach the content and to measure student achievement with local alternative assessments, including authentic or performance assessments. School divisions must certify annually that they have provided instruction and administered an alternative assessment, consistent with Board of Education guidelines, to students in grades and subject areas that no longer have a corresponding SOL test.
Current guidance for continued implementation of local alternative assessments, approved by the Virginia Board of Education on July 27, 2023, is provided in the Guidelines for Local Alternative Assessments: 2023-2024 and Beyond. These guidelines recommend that school divisions use the integrated reading and writing component, which will be administered to all students as part of the Grade 5 SOL Reading test beginning in spring 2024, to fulfill the requirement that school divisions administer local alternative assessments for Grade 5 Writing . School divisions are to continue using the common rubrics, linked below in each content-specific section, when scoring student responses to performance assessments or performance tasks included among the local alternative assessments in these courses. Continued use of the Virginia Quality Criteria Tool for Performance Assessments is also encouraged.
Balanced Assessment Plans
School divisions are required to develop Balanced Assessment Plans for the content areas and courses requiring local alternative assessments. Implementation Support for Balanced Assessment Plans (Attachment B, Superintendent's Memo #214-21) clarifies the requirements for these plans and offers suggestions for consideration when developing these plans. Beginning with the 2023-2024 school year, school divisions using the integrated reading and writing component of the Grade 5 Standards of Learning Reading test to fulfill the local alternative assessment requirement in Grade 5 Writing are not required to develop a Balanced Assessment Plan for this content area.
Content-Specific Information and Resources
English: Writing
Grade 5 Writing
Beginning in spring 2024, all students participating in the Grade 5 Reading SOL test will be administered an integrated reading and writing component. School divisions are encouraged to use this integrated reading and writing component to fulfill the local alternative assessment requirement in Grade 5 Writing. Divisions using this component in this manner will not be required to develop a Balanced Assessment Plan for Grade 5 Writing. Please note that it is not permitted to administer local alternative assessments for Grade 5 Writing in lieu of the Grade 5 Reading SOL test integrated reading and writing component.
Supports for Grade 5 Writing include:
- Grade 5 Writing (Word) – rubrics based on the 2017 English Standards of Learning for use during instruction in the 2019-2020 school year and beyond
- Upper Elementary Scoring Rubrics (Word) - scoring rubrics based on the 2017 English Standards of Learning to be used when scoring local alternative assessments. (Note: This document was previously named “Grade 5 Writing Scoring Rubric.” The name has been changed but other information in the document remains the same.) Beginning in spring 2024, this rubric will be used to score writing responses for the Grade 5 Reading SOL test integrated reading and writing component.
- Menu of Grade 5 Writing Options (Word) - sample tasks based on the 2017 English Standards of Learning for use by school divisions when creating local alternative assessments
- Understand Scoring - available for use during local training for focused holistic scoring. This online application provides information about scoring the Integrated Reading and Writing component of the Reading SOL assessments, which can be used to meet requirements for local alternative assessments in Grade 5 Writing. Scoring rubrics and anchor papers that illustrate each score point for Composing/Written Expression and Usage and Mechanics domains are provided to assist teachers in preparing students for Virginia's writing assessments.
- Understand Scoring Presentation- PowerPoint presentation that may be used by divisions to assist with local training for scoring using Virginia's writing rubrics.
End-of-Course Writing
Support materials for the use of local performance assessments to verify credit in writing can be found on the English, Reading, & Literacy Assessment Resources page for Local Performance Assessments to Verify Credit in Writing.
History and Social Science
The resources provided are for use with the 2015 History and Social Science Standards of Learning. Visit the Assessment Resources webpage for History & Social Science for additional performance assessment resources, including those for school divisions using state-developed performance assessments to verify credits in history and social science.
Grade 3 History, U.S. History to 1865, and U.S. History: 1865 to the Present
Local alternative assessments, including performance assessments, are to be administered in place of the eliminated Standards of Learning tests. A Balanced Assessment Plan is required. Appropriate testing conditions for the administration of local alternative assessments in Grade 3 History are determined by the local school division. Supports for these content courses include:
- Common rubrics: The common rubrics for history and social science are not grade or course specific. School divisions have the opportunity and autonomy to select the common rubric that best suits the needs of their students when scoring local alternative assessments in grade 3.
- History and Social Science Scoring Supports (PPT) - These slides from the webinar hosted on March 31, 2021, by the Office of Student Assessment and Office of Humanities provide an overview of resources to support scoring performance assessments and performance tasks using the state common rubrics.
End-of-Course History and Social Science Courses
- Support materials for school divisions using state-developed performance tasks in conjunction with other local assessments to confer locally awarded verified credits in high school courses eligible for verified credit are located on the History and Social Science Instruction webpage for Assessment Resources.
Mathematics
Performance assessment resources for mathematics are available to support teachers in implementing the 2016 Mathematics Standards of Learning. Teachers are encouraged to not only use these tasks with their students, but also to endeavor to implement them with fidelity by utilizing the detailed information provided in the task implementation templates. Please refer to the Rich Mathematical Tasks webpage for more information and linked resources provided for K-8, Algebra I, Geometry, and Algebra II. In addition to the tasks themselves, resources include a blank template, the Rich Mathematical Task Rubric (Word) to use for scoring, and the Planning for Remote Implementation of Rich Mathematical Tasks (Word) guidance.
Science
The resources provided are for use with the 2018 Science Standards of Learning. Visit the Performance Assessment section of the Science Assessment Resources webpage for additional performance assessment resources. These include common rubrics for Scientific Investigation (K-2, 6-8, and 9-12) and sample performance assessments for grade 6 (Meaningful Watershed Education Experience) and Chemistry (Stoichiometry).
Grade 3 Science
Local alternative assessments, including performance assessments, are to be administered in place of the eliminated Standards of Learning test. A Balanced Assessment Plan is required. Appropriate testing conditions for the administration of local alternative assessments in Grade 3 Science are determined by the local school division. Supports for Grade 3 Science include:
- Common rubrics
- Sample Third Grade Performance Assessments
- Lemonade Stand (Word)
- Simple Machines (Word)
- Soil Investigation (Word)
Resources from VDOE for Any Content Area
- Assessment Inventory Tool (Word) – sample tool for use by schools and school divisions. Use of this Assessment Inventory tool is not required; however, schools and school divisions are encouraged to use an assessment review process to support the development of Balanced Assessment Plans.
- Assessment Literacy Glossary (Word) – a list of terms and definitions related to Local Alternative Assessments (updated February 2019)
- Balanced Assessment Plans Desk Review (PPT) – presented as a webinar on May 29, 2020. This presentation includes the process for these desk reviews, the findings, examples of best practices, and expectations for Balanced Assessment Plans beginning with the 2020-2021 school year.
- The Framework for Local Alternative Assessment Implementation (PDF) – provides common language for school divisions to use in determining their progress in implementing performance assessments and in identifying next steps.
- Frequently Asked Questions: Performance Assessment (Word) – provides information related to the use of performance tasks and performance assessments that are not used to verify credit (updated February 2019)
- Local Alternative Assessment Desk Review Form (Word)– form to be completed and submitted by school divisions selected for desk review of the local alternative assessments in one or more content areas.
- Local Alternative Assessments and Balanced Assessment Plans in 2022-2023 and Beyond - the presentation slides (PPT) and YouTube recording, from the webinar recorded on October 24, 2022, share results and findings from desk reviews conducted in 2021-2022 and recommendations for 2022-2023 and beyond.
- Local Alternative Assessments: Reporting to Parents and Reminders for Scoring (PPT) - provides expectations and examples for reporting a student's results on local alternative assessments to parents and reminders for scoring local performance assessments.
- Overview of Balanced Assessment Plans (Superintendent's Memo 181-19-A) (Word) – provides guidance and considerations to assist school divisions as they develop Balanced Assessment Plans. School divisions should also reference the Implementation Support for Balanced Assessment Plans (Superintendent's Memo 214-21B) (Word) in the Balanced Assessment Plan section above for additional clarification in 2021-2022 and beyond.
- Performance Task Development Cycle (PDF) – a flow chart for the development of performance tasks
- Play Video: Audio Walk-Through of the Framework for Alternative Assessment Implementation
- Principles of Scoring Student Work (Word) – Principles of Scoring Student Work was authored by Stanford Center for Assessment, Learning, & Equity (SCALE). This document provides guidance for using a rubric to score performance tasks and performance assessments.
- Summative Assessment vs. Formative Assessment (PPT) – provides information about the differences between summative and formative assessment and the instructional benefits of formative assessment.
- Virginia Quality Criteria Tool for Performance Assessments (Word) – details a set of criteria for the development of performance assessments that measure the application of content knowledge and skills. (Updated June 2019)
Professional Development
- Supporting Instruction and Deeper Learning through Balanced Assessment – Preliminary conference materials from sessions offered in May and June of 2019
- Performance Assessment Assurances: Next Steps for Leading Deeper Learning in Virginia – Conference materials from sessions offered in May and June of 2018
- Assessing For Deeper Learning: A Transformative Pathway to Prepare Virginia Students for the Future (Word) – 2016 Conference Materials